Mahler: Symphony No. 6 [Hybrid SACD]
![Mahler: Symphony No. 6 [Hybrid SACD]](/images/Mahler-Symphony-No-6-Hybrid-SACD-B0015LPS0A-L.jpg)
List Price:
Our Price: $10.92
You Save: $11.06 (50%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Category: Music CD
See more CD details
Buy this Music CD at online store in your country
Canadian Music Store
Canadian Music Store
CD Details
Composer: MahlerConductor: Bernard Haitink
Orchestra: Chicago Symphony Orchestra
Edition: Music CD
Audio: English (Unknown)
Format: Hybrid SACD - DSD
CD Release Date: 2008-04-08
Music Label: Cso Resound
Soundtracks:
Music CD 1
- Symphony No. 6 in A minor ('Tragic'): Allegro energico, ma non troppo: Heftig, aber markig
- Symphony No. 6 in A minor ('Tragic'): Scherzo: Wuchtig
- Symphony No. 6 in A minor ('Tragic'): Andante moderato
- Symphony No. 6 in A minor ('Tragic'): Finale: Allegro moderato - Allegro energico
Music reviews of Mahler: Symphony No. 6 [Hybrid SACD]
Music Review: well played, but Haitink is excrutiatingly slow and dull
Rating: 2 Stars
Please note: I listened to the sacd/cd hybrid version, but just on a regular cd player. I do not own any surround sound equipment.
It gives me absolutely no joy to be so negative about this release. I was hoping for this to be an improvement over Haitink's CSO Mahler 3rd, which ain't bad (not great, either), but this is even more disappointing. It makes me wish now that I had never said anything nasty about his recent French one for the Naive label (L'Orchestre National de France). That one was positively thrilling compared to this snooze-fest. For starters, this is among the very slowest versions of the Mahler 6th symphony ever recorded (Sinopoli has the slowest one on record). But it possess none of the sleezy decadence that made the Sinopoli M6 sort of interesting (way too slow in the andante movement, though), much less the steely resolve and grim determination of the old John Barbirolli one. Haitink is just grim . . . and dour. Surely the CSO could have held off for some fresh blood to offer a few new or interesting insights. I just don't find anything new or interesting here at all. Let's begin on the gruesome details.
I have no problem with any conductor starting M6 with such a slow march, especially when you have low strings that are as strong as those in Chicago. But that also means that you have to conjure up some degree of contrast when you reach the sweeping second subject; the so-called "Alma theme". Haitink boldly fails to go where a few men have, indeed, gone. He's just slow and trudgy from start to finish - well over 25 minutes worth! I could have forgiven all that if he had simply whipped up some genuine excitement at the close of the movement. But just as with several spots in his recent CSO M3, he gets a lot of loudness from the famous Chicago brass, but with insufficient forward motion or sense of enthusiasm to go along with it. All this makes me think that Barbirolli made the right call by leaving out the exposition repeat. If you think that tragic means dark, heavy, and slow - from start to finish, mind you - your ship has arrived.
Scherzo: why bother? I think this performance is a good argument for dropping the scherzo altogether - thus ending the never ending debate over movement order, once and for all - and turning Mahler 6 into the greatest three movement symphony every written. Seriously, this is about as dull and poker-faced as you'll ever hear this oh-so-spooky scherzo. It's very well played, and little more. If you want to hear what this scherzo can - and should - contribute to the overall narrative of the symphony, try Rattle (either one); Gergiev/LSO (just came out too); Neumann/Czech Phil. (Canyon Classics), or Macal/Czech Phil. (Exton). Even Sinopoli provided some interesting contrast with his Mahler 6 sludge-fest, just by taking the scherzo at a relatively quick tempo.
Andante Moderato: Haitink isn't ridiculously slow with this - well less than 17 minutes, actually. But it might as well have been 19 minutes. Again, the playing is there but not much else. For example, there's absolutely nothing graphic or outdoors-y about the brief "Alpine" passage, located about six minutes in, under Haitink's dreary direction (rising, unsion horns; on-stage cowbells; naive sounding solo trumpet; swirling violin trills) - how could it all have fallen so flat? On the plus side, the Chicago strings do themselves proud over the movement's climactic passage. But it's all too little, too late. What's all the romantic fuss about?
Finale: from bad to worse. For example, let's just take the slow introductory section. There's a brief, funeral dirge for low woodwinds, followed by the low brass, that's located no more than 90 seconds into the movement. Haitink takes this at an extremely slow tempo, but then fails to make a ritard at the one spot where he could have inserted a huge one to great effect: the last A-major to A-minor chord meltdown, just before the movement begins its first allegro (fast) episode.
Haitink also fails to build up the tempo while traversing the chromatic (half step) harmonies leading up to the first hammer blow - which, by the way, is rather underwhelming in comparison to all the loud brass surrounding it - or approach the second one with much sense of trepidation, for that matter. Both Gergiev and Tennstedt (1991) are far better at objectifying the differences between the two hammer-strokes, just by the way that they approach them. As for the hammer-strokes themselves, I'm more bothered by the balances at those critical junctures, than by the slightly underwhelming sound of the hammer itself (the second one gets reinforced by the optional, additional percussion).
The famous Chicago brass dominate at those big junctures, just as they should, but to the extent that the brass sound as though they're sitting in the front row along with everyone else. No doubt, that kind of effect is a byproduct of Mr. Mallison's recording technique (very wide sounding), along with the relatively shallow depth of Chicago's Orchestra Hall. As so often happens, the strong Chicago trumpets make little or no distinction across the various gradations of forte - it's all just equally loud. Again, that's probably more an issue of logistics and acoustics, than any negligence on their part. I just don't like it when the trumpets sound front and center - literally! Perhaps a better solution would have been to put the horns where the trumpets normally are (front and center, but along the back), and put the trumpets more off to the side.
Well, why go on? I could point out that Haitink interestingly makes a huge ritard for the brief "false victory parade" passage, located before the spot where the third hammer-stroke originally existed (and sometimes gets reinserted) - and gets his horns to blast a true fortissimo there too - but then fails to bring out the all-important percussion underneath the horns and sweeping violins. But what would be the point? The battle is over, and so am I.
If you want the big guns of an American orchestra in Mahler 6, I would strongly recommend sticking to the recent Eschenbach/Philly one on Ondine. While Eschenbach may not be perfect either, he's vastly more varied and interesting with his conducting than Haitink. The balances are also far, far better than here. And while I'm not a huge fan of Tilson-Thomas' Mahler in general (his 8th should be great), his sixth is much better too. It's also a shame that DG never remastered and reissued their Abbado/CSO M6 on to their fine "Originals" series, because it's really pretty good - much better than this. As for Haitink, his best Mahler 6 is still the very first one he made with the Concertgebouw. His Berlin remake was pretty dull in the first two movements, but the slow movement and finale were darn near excellent - much, much, much better than this. Even his French one had its moments.
Perhaps these would have appeared to have been great performances in a "live" situation (albeit loud), but something simply isn't translating on to disc. Instead, I wish that the well meaning folks at the CSO had waited for someone new to get a crack at it. In my opinion, this is a wasted effort for the CSO. And I take no pleasure in saying that.
Classical CDs
Music Genres
Bestsellers in Classical CDs
Winterscapesby London Philharmonic
Prophetic Voice; Published: 2000-07; Audio CD; Book
Best price: $2.75
Price in other shops:
The Queen, the Bear, & the Bumblebeeby Dini Petty
Children's Group; Published: 2001-03; Audio CD; Book
Best price: $13.38
Price in other shops:
Classical Kids - Beethoven Lives Upstairs CdrRelease date: 2000-04-05; Music CD
Best price: $24.98
Tchaikovsky (Life and Works (Naxos))by Malcolm Sinclair, Jeremy Siepmann
Naxos; Published: 2003-11; Audio CD; Book
Best price: $35.99
![Jose Carreras - Jubileum Concert [VHS] Image](/images/Jose-Carreras-Jubileum-Concert-VHS-1584481471-X.jpg){kind=small}
Jose Carreras - Jose Carreras - Jubileum Concert [VHS]Sling Shot; Release date: 2000-04-18; VHS Tape; VHS Video
Best price: $5.86
Price in other shops:
![Tchaikovsky - The Nutcracker / Nureyev, Park, Royal Ballet [VHS] Image](/images/Tchaikovsky-The-Nutcracker-Nureyev-Park-Royal-Ballet-VHS-156127092X-X.jpg){kind=small}
Tchaikovsky - The Nutcracker / Nureyev, Park, Royal Ballet [VHS]Kultur Video; Release date: 1997-09-09; VHS Tape; VHS Video
Best price: $29.89
Price in other shops:
![Lonely Town Lonley Street / Sergeant's Early Dream [VHS] Image](/images/Lonely-Town-Lonley-Street-Sergeant-Early-Dream-VHS-1561270857-X.jpg){kind=small}
Rambert Dance Company - Lonely Town Lonley Street / Sergeant's Early Dream [VHS]Kultur Video; Release date: 1997-10-28; VHS Tape; VHS Video
Best price: $14.99
Price in other shops:
Winter Music: Composing the Northby John Luther Adams
Wesleyan; Published: 2004-11-10; Hardcover; Book
Best price: $21.90
Price in other shops:
![Puccini - La Fanciulla del West / Santi, Domingo, Neblett, Royal Opera Covent Garden [VHS] Image](/images/Puccini-La-Fanciulla-del-West-Santi-Domingo-Neblett-Royal-Opera-Covent-Garden-VHS-0769720382-X.jpg){kind=small}
Puccini - La Fanciulla del West / Santi, Domingo, Neblett, Royal Opera Covent Garden [VHS]Kultur Video; Release date: 1999-05-25; VHS Tape; VHS Video
Best price: $6.38
Price in other shops:
![Verdi - Falstaff / Giulini, Bruson, Ricciarelli, Nucci, Royal Opera Covent Garden [VHS] Image](/images/Verdi-Falstaff-Giulini-Bruson-Ricciarelli-Nucci-Royal-Opera-Covent-Garden-VHS-0769720358-X.jpg){kind=small}
Verdi - Falstaff / Giulini, Bruson, Ricciarelli, Nucci, Royal Opera Covent Garden [VHS]Kultur Video; Release date: 1999-05-25; VHS Tape; VHS Video
Best price: $12.95
Price in other shops:
Similar CDs
![Richard Strauss: Also sprach Zarathustra; Ein Heldenleben [Hybrid SACD] Image](/images/Richard-Strauss-Also-sprach-Zarathustra-Ein-Heldenleben-Hybrid-SACD-B0002TKFQI-X.jpg)
Richard Strauss: Also sprach Zarathustra; Ein Heldenleben [Hybrid SACD]Release date: 2004-09-14; Music CD
Best price: $7.54
Price in other shops:
![Mahler: Symphony No. 7 [Hybrid SACD] Image](/images/Mahler-Symphony-No-7-Hybrid-SACD-B001AS69P6-X.jpg)
Gergiev, London Symphony Orchestra - Mahler: Symphony No. 7 [Hybrid SACD]Release date: 2008-08-12; Music CD
Best price: $12.14
Price in other shops:
Michelle Deyoung - Mahler: Symphony No. 3Release date: 2007-05-08; Music CD
Best price: $4.12
Price in other shops:
![Mahler: Symphony 8 [Blu-ray] Image](/images/Mahler-Symphony-8-Blu-ray-B005HK8L1I-X.jpg)
Mahler: Symphony 8 [Blu-ray]Release date: 2011-09-27; Published: 2011-10-14; Blu-ray
Best price: $28.41
Price in other shops:
Mahler: Symphony No. 8 (Hybr)Release date: 2009-04-14; Music CD
Best price: $12.72
Price in other shops:
![Mussorgsky: Pictures at an Exhibition, A Night on Bald Mountain, and Other Russian Showpieces [Hybrid SACD] Image](/images/Mussorgsky-Pictures-at-an-Exhibition-A-Night-on-Bald-Mountain-and-Other-Russian-Showpieces-Hybrid-SACD-B0002TKFRM-X.jpg)
Mussorgsky: Pictures at an Exhibition, A Night on Bald Mountain, and Other Russian Showpieces [Hybrid SACD]Release date: 2004-09-14; Music CD
Best price: $7.37
Price in other shops:
![Mahler: Symphony No. 6 [Hybrid SACD] Image](/images/Mahler-Symphony-No-6-Hybrid-SACD-B0013V9RHW-X.jpg)
Mahler: Symphony No. 6 [Hybrid SACD]Release date: 2008-04-08; Music CD
Best price: $6.86
Price in other shops:
![Bruckner 7 [Hybrid SACD] Image](/images/Bruckner-7-Hybrid-SACD-B000VR053O-X.jpg)
Bruckner 7 [Hybrid SACD]Release date: 2007-10-09; Music CD
Best price: $9.08
Price in other shops:
Mahler: Symphony No. 1Release date: 2009-03-02; Music CD
Best price: $13.20
Price in other shops:
Mahler: Symphony No. 2Release date: 2009-11-17; Music CD
Best price: $13.94
Price in other shops: